top of page

Honthorst’s The Concert: Music, Company, and the Art of Harmony

Oct 7
4 min read

A raised glass catches the eye near the top of the painting. Beneath it, a smiling young man brings a finger toward his lips. Around him, mouths open, hands gather over strings, and heads incline toward the music. We cannot hear the performance, but we can recognize the small negotiations that let people make something together.

Gerrit van Honthorst’s The Concert invites that kind of looking: attentive to the individual, then to the group. Its pleasure lies in how many separate actions the eye can follow without losing the sense of a shared occasion.

Eight musicians and companions gather around open music books in Gerrit van Honthorst’s The Concert, 1623.

Gerrit van Honthorst, The Concert, 1623. Oil on canvas, 123.5 × 205 cm. National Gallery of Art, Washington; Patrons’ Permanent Fund and Florian Carr Fund, 2013.38.1. Public domain.

The artwork at a glance: Gerrit van Honthorst (Dutch, 1592–1656) · 1623 · Oil on canvas · National Gallery of Art, Washington. [1]

In this article

Enter the gathering

Start with the figure whose back faces us. His dark cloak fills much of the lower left corner, a substantial shape against the pale faces beyond. Follow the red of his sleeve toward his extended hand. That movement carries us across the tabletop, into the space where the others are concentrating.

The table gives the gathering a firm horizontal base. Above it, almost everything tilts: a head, a wrist, an instrument’s neck, a feather. This difference matters. The stable lower edge allows the figures to feel animated without making the whole image seem unstable.

There is very little empty space between the performers. One shoulder disappears behind another; a hand enters a neighboring patch of color. For this viewer, the overlaps make closeness the painting’s subject as much as music. Each person remains distinct, but nobody occupies an entirely separate world.

A painter known for darkness, seen in daylight

Born in Utrecht, Honthorst trained with Abraham Bloemaert before spending years in Rome. He returned to Utrecht in 1620 and became an influential Dutch interpreter of Caravaggio. His career later extended to royal patrons, including Charles I in England. The National Gallery in London places candlelit scenes among the works for which he became especially known. [3]

Its Christ before the High Priest, painted around 1617, offers a useful comparison. The museum describes a composition organized around a candle, with faces emerging from the surrounding darkness. Light concentrates the encounter and leaves much of the room unseen. [4]

The Concert offers a different experience. Its broad illumination lets us move freely among faces, fabrics, and instruments. There is no visible flame gathering everyone into a small circle. The background remains light enough to read, while the folds of blue and red clothing hold their own against the skin. Drama survives here as movement and color.

Detail of the woman in blue playing a lute, with light across her hand and the instrument.

Detail: the lute player. Follow the changes from skin to polished wood to folded blue fabric.

Look at the hands

The faces may attract us first, but the hands give the picture much of its structure. On the right, the lute player’s fingers spread across the instrument’s rounded body. Near the center, another hand curls around a neck crowded with strings. Below them, the foreground musician directs his bow toward the pages.

Try following only these gestures. Their directions repeatedly bring the eye back toward the table. Then look upward to the raised glass: it interrupts that downward movement, lifting the gathering into a more openly celebratory register. The image can feel absorbed and sociable at once.

The NGA identifies the instruments as a bass viol, violin, bandora, and lute. In his catalogue essay, Arthur K. Wheelock Jr. notes that the music itself has not been identified. We can describe the visible act of performing without pretending to know the song. [2]

The court beyond the picture

Honthorst’s courtly connections give the scene a wider setting. Elizabeth Stuart and her husband Frederick became queen and king of Bohemia in 1619, then went into exile after his defeat in 1620. They settled in The Hague. Honthorst later painted numerous portraits of the couple and their children, as the National Gallery’s account of Elizabeth explains. [5]

Wheelock proposes that Frederick and Elizabeth may have commissioned The Concert as a gift to Prince Maurits of Orange. A resemblance between the foreground musician and a contemporary depiction of Frederick supports the suggestion, but no document confirms the gift. The painting’s proposed identification in a 1632 palace inventory is also uncertain. [2]

Detail of the foreground musician’s hand and bow pointing across open music books on the patterned table.

Detail: the bow and the open scores. A small directing gesture gives the surrounding activity a shared focus.

Could harmony carry a political message?

Wheelock’s interpretation connects the directing musician with an ideal of leadership: different participants create harmony by responding to guidance. Under that reading, the painting could also have supported Frederick’s political cause. This remains a scholarly interpretation tied to the proposed patronage, rather than a securely documented explanation of the commission. [2]

The suggestion changes the weight of a small gesture. A bow aimed at a score can still belong to an enjoyable performance, while also inviting a larger question about how people act together. The pleasure of the scene need not disappear when we notice the possibility of authority within it.

Return to the raised glass

After the history, look again at the young man above the central group. His glass and finger seem to pull in different directions: one expansive, the other restraining. That tension is a good place to leave the painting open.

We may arrive for the brilliant clothing and stay for the relationships. The Concert gives us several ways to participate: follow the bow, study the hands, meet a smile, or imagine listening. Its lasting invitation is to notice how a gathering is made, one person’s attention answering another’s.

Continue looking with Havenest’s guide to reading a still life, then explore how light shapes encounters in Vermeer’s scenes of private life.

Sources and further reading

Written by Havenest Editorial · Historical research checked against museum collection records. Visual readings are the editorial interpretation of the artwork.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page